The 5 Dog Poop Bags I’ve Tried: Which Ones Would I Buy Again?

img 1580
img 1580

The 5 Dog Poop Bags I’ve Tried: Which Ones Would I Buy Again?

Dog poop bags are one of those products that I use everyday as a dog parent. I never thought too much about the differences in quality between brands until I realized just how many I go through each day.

I’ve tried a few different brands over the years, including inexpensive dollar-store bags to compostable options, and I’ve definitely found some that I keep coming back to. So if you’re wondering which dog poop bags I’ve actually used and which ones I’d buy again, here’s my honest take.

For context: These have all been used with a medium-sized dog.

*This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. I may also earn a small commission from other affiliate programs at no extra cost to you.

Quick Comparison

Poop Bag

Thickness

Easy to Tear

Leaks

Odor Control

Cost

Would I Buy Again?

Earth Rated, Unscented

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

⭐⭐⭐⭐

⭐⭐⭐⭐

Yes

Earth Rated, Compostable

⭐⭐⭐1/2

⭐⭐⭐⭐

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

⭐⭐⭐

⭐⭐⭐

Yes

Top Paw, Extra Thick

⭐⭐⭐⭐

⭐⭐⭐⭐

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

⭐⭐⭐

⭐⭐⭐⭐

Yes, if needed

Eco Potty, Compostable

⭐⭐⭐1/2

⭐⭐⭐

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

⭐⭐⭐

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Yes, if needed

Sparky Poopy Sac

⭐⭐

⭐⭐

⭐⭐⭐⭐

⭐⭐

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

No

Earth Rated Unscented Poop Bags

My rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5)

This is my favourite of all the bags I’ve tried, and the one I’ve been using for the past couple of years. It’s thick, durable and has never ripped or leaked on me. And TMI – I’ve dealt with my fair share of messy poop.

I also really like the texture, large size and odor control. They’re unscented, which I prefer over scented, although there is a slight smell if you get really close to the bag. They’re easy to tear off the roll without accidentally ripping the bag, and there’s even an indicator when you have three bags left, which is very helpful for remembering to grab a new roll. 

The bags come on a compact roll that fits easily into a poop bag holder, or you can just grab one and stick it in your pocket before heading out.

They’re not the cheapest option out there, but are quite comparable.  Although I don’t mind paying a little more for a bag I know I can rely on. 

Earth Rated says these bags are made with 65% certified post-consumer recycled plastic, which I like. Of course, they’re still plastic bags, so there is an environmental trade-off like with most dog poop bags.

Would I buy them again? Absolutely.

Where I buy them: Amazon, pet stores and occasionally Winners.

[Shop Earth Rated Unscented Poop Bags →]

Earth Rated Compostable Poop Bags

My rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5)

I’ve recently switched to the compostable version of Earth Rated, and overall, I’ve been really happy with them.

They’re noticeably thinner than the regular Earth Rated bags because they’re made from a different material, but they’ve still been durable and I’ve never had one leak on me. They have a good texture, are a nice large size and have the same three-bag-left indicator that I love.

One difference I’ve noticed is odor control. Since they’re compostable, they don’t have quite the same odor control as the regular bags. It doesn’t really bother me on regular dog walks, especially knowing they are compostable.

My one issue is that I’ve on rare occasionally ripped one while taking it off the roll. That said, I’ve never had one rip while actually using it to pick up poop.

They’re also on the more expensive side, especially compared with other compostable options.

Would I buy them again? Yes, these are my go-to compostabledog poop bags. The very occasional wasted bag is a minor annoyance, but they’ve otherwise been reliable for me.

Where I buy them: Amazon, pet stores and occasionally Winners.

[Shop Earth Rated Compostable Poop Bags →]

Top Paw Extra Thick Dog Poop Bags

My rating: ⭐⭐⭐½ (3.5/5)

I picked these up at my closest PetSmart when I wanted to try another thicker poop bag. Compared with some dollar-store options I’ve tried, these feel thicker and more durable, while still tearing easily from the roll without ripping the actual bag. Though, the first bag on the roll sometimes gets stuck on the sticker that holds the unused roll together.

They’ve held up well for me and I haven’t had any issues with leaking. The odor control isn’t the best I’ve experienced, but it’s not something I really notice during a normal walk. They’re also a good large size, come on a compact roll that fits easily into a poop bag dispenser, and I think they’re a good value for the number of bags you get. I also like that they come in different colours. I tried the multicolor pack, but they have a variety of colors and prints to choose from for those who enjoy that.

My only real complaint is the texture. This is definitely a personal preference, but I find these bags feel a little crunchy and stiff compared with my favourite Earth Rated Extra Thick bags, which have a softer, nicer-feeling texture. That said, the Top Paw bags still get the job done.

Would I buy them again? Yes, if I needed them. They’re not my personal favourite based on feel and odor control, but they’re a decent, reasonably priced option that I’d be comfortable purchasing again.

Where I bought them: PetSmart

[Shop Top Paw Extra Thick Dog Poop Bags →]

EcoPotty Unscented Compostable Bags

My rating: ⭐⭐⭐½ (3.5/5)

These were actually one of my go-to bags for a while, mainly because they’re reasonably priced, come in a large quantity, easy for me to pick up while grocery shopping at Costco, and compostable.

Like most compostable bags I’ve tried, they’re thinner than a traditional plastic poop bag and have that slightly different texture. I’ve never had an issue with one leaking, but I have had some frustrating problems with them ripping.

Sometimes the sticker on the roll doesn’t come off easily and tears the first bag, and occasionally the bag itself stretches or tears when I’m pulling it off. If I have an intact bag, though, it’s held up well and I’ve never had an issue with it leaking.

Would I buy them again? I don’t regularly anymore because the ripping became annoying, but I wouldn’t hesitate to buy them again if I was out of bags and happened to be at Costco. They’re a good value for the number of bags you get; I’d just expect to lose a few to the roll.

Where I buy them: Costco, so you’ll need a Costco membership.

[Shop Eco Potty Compostable Poop Bags for Pets →]

Sparky Poopy Sac

My rating: ⭐⭐ (2/5)

I’ll be honest: I bought these from Dollarama because I’d run out of my usual bags and needed something quickly.

They’re inexpensive, unscented and a good size (though just a little smaller than the other brands I mentioned above), and I haven’t had an issue with leaking as long as the bag is intact. My biggest issue is that they tend to rip when I’m taking them off the roll, which means I’ve had to throw quite a few away before even using them.

They’re also on a longer roll that isn’t designed to fit in a traditional poop bag dispenser. That’s not necessarily a dealbreaker, but I personally prefer the smaller, compact rolls that I can keep in a dispenser on the leash or throw into my pocket.

They’re thinner than the other bags I’ve tried, and I also find they have less odor control.

Would I buy them again? No. While they’re cheaper and could work for lighter use, I’d rather spend a little more on a bag I know I can rely on.

Where to buy them: Dollarama.

So, Which Poop Bags Would I Actually Buy Again?

My clear favourite is the Earth Rated Unscented Poop Bags. After using them for years, they’ve consistently been durable, easy to use and reliable, and I’ve never had one leak on me. I also like that they are a Canadian company.

I’ve since switched to Earth Rated’s compostable bags, which I also really like. They’re a little thinner, have slightly less odor control and cost more, but those are trade-offs I’m comfortable with.

The EcoPotty bags are a decent budget-friendly option, especially if you’re already shopping at Costco, but the more-than occasional tearing is why I eventually moved away from them.

And the Sparky Poopy Sac bags are the ones I wouldn’t repurchase. They work in a pinch, but the frequent tearing makes them more frustrating than they’re worth to me.

At the end of the day, poop bags aren’t exactly the most exciting purchase, but after you’ve used enough of them, you definitely notice the difference between a bag you can trust and one you’re nervous to pull off the roll.

What poop bags do you swear by?

Shop the review

Shop my favourite dog poop bags on Amazon

Earth Rated Unscented Poop Bags

The dog poop bags I’ve been using for years

-> Shop Earth Rated Dog Poop Bags on Amazon

Earth Rated Compostable Poop Bags, Unscented

The compostable dog poops bags I recently switched, from the same brand I’ve been using for years

-> Shop Earth Rated Compostable Dog Poop Bags on Amazon