Why Earth Rated Is My Favourite Dog Poop Bag

untitled design (7)
untitled design (7)

Why Earth Rated Is My Favourite Dog Poop Bag

When it comes to dog poop bags, I’ve tried quite a few over the years. Some have been perfectly fine, while some have been a little frustrating. But one brand has become my favourite.

My go-to? Earth Rated Extra Thick Unscented Dog Poop Bags.

I’ve been using them for about two years now, and they are the bags I buy on repeat.

*This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. I may also earn a small commission from other affiliate programs at no extra cost to you.

Why I Started Using Earth Rated

I originally wanted a poop bag that I could easily order online AND that was more eco-friendly.

After browsing Amazon and reading through reviews, I decided to give Earth Rated a try. I ended up loving their dog poop bags that they have been my go-to ever since. 

What I Like About Them

They’re Thick and Durable

These are noticeably thicker than some of the other poop bags I’ve tried, which is one of the biggest reasons I keep buying them.

I’ve used them for about two years and have never had one leak or rip on me while actually picking up poop and carrying the bag during a walk.

And, without getting too graphic, I’ve dealt with my fair share of messy poop over the years. These have held up every time.

They also have good odour control, considering they are a poop bag. 

They’re a Good Size

They’re a classic large-size poop bag, which has plenty of room. For context, I have a medium-sized dog and there’s lots of extra room to spare.

They Tear Easily

The bags come on a compact roll and tear off easily without ripping the bag itself.

I can keep a roll in a poop bag holder attached to the leash, or just grab a roll and stick it in my pocket before heading out.

I Like That They’re Unscented

I buy the unscented version and don’t notice any obvious smell when using them. If you actually put the bag up to your nose, there is a slight smell, but nothing noticeable during a normal walk.

They also have scented options if that’s something you prefer.

I Like the Recycled Plastic

One thing I particularly like about the standard Earth Rated bags is that, according to the brand, they’re made with 65% certified post-consumer recycled plastic. 

Dog poop bags are something I go through daily, so I like knowing that the plastic used in these bags is partially made from recycled material.

It’s not a perfect solution, but it’s something I appreciate when I’m buying a product I’ll use over and over again.

Is There Anything I Don't Like?

Honestly, it’s hard for me to come up with much.

They’re reliable, durable, a good size and I’ve never had one leak or rip on me.

While you can find cheaper poop bags, I think they are priced very reasonably and comparable to others I see at the pet store. Even still, I usually look for them on sale like I do for most of my pet products. 

What About the Compostable Version?

I’ve recently started using Earth Rated’s compostable poop bags as well, and I really like these too.

They’re thinner than the regular bags and have that slightly different texture that you tend to get with compostable poop bags. I’ve still found them durable and haven’t had an issue with them leaking.

There are a few trade-offs, though. I find they have a little less odor control, they’re more expensive, and you need to make sure you actually have somewhere appropriate to compost them rather than assuming they can just go in your regular garbage bin.

For me, the compostable bags are a great option when I want a more environmentally conscious choice. But for everyday use, I still tend to reach for the regular Extra Thick bags because I prefer the thickness and they’re a little easier on the wallet.

[Shop the Earth Rated Compostable Poop Bags →]

Who Are These Good For?

Honestly, I’d recommend these to pretty much any dog owner looking for a reliable everyday poop bag.

They’re especially worth considering if you:

  • Want a thicker, durable bag
  • Have a medium or larger dog
  • Prefer unscented bags
  • Want a compact roll that fits in a poop bag holder
  • Don’t want to worry about bags ripping or leaking
  • Like the idea of using bags made partially with recycled plastic

Would I Buy Them Again?

Absolutely.

I’ve tried and purchased plenty of other poop bags over the years, but Earth Rated Extra Thick Unscented bags have remained my go-to. 

They’re one of those dog products that aren’t particularly exciting, but when you use something every single day, having a bag that you know is going to do its job makes a difference.

I also really like that Earth Rated is a Canadian company, and the fact that their standard bags are made with recycled plastic is another reason I feel good about continuing to buy them.

Shop the post

Shop the products I mentioned

Earth Rated Unscented Poop Bags

The dog poop bags I’ve been using for years

-> Shop Earth Rated Dog Poop Bags on Amazon

Earth Rated Compostable Poop Bags, Unscented

The compostable dog poops bags I recently switched, from the same brand I’ve been using for years

-> Shop Earth Rated Compostable Dog Poop Bags on Amazon